Doctor Operates on the Wrong Eye

An ophthalmologist is facing a lawsuit and revocation of his medical license after operating on the wrong eye. The Chicago woman, Sutton Dryfhout, says she came in for a routine cyst removal surgery and experienced a living nightmare. According to Dryfhout, Dr. Benjamin Ticho realized his mistake after the surgery when Dryfhout was already in post-operative care. Amazingly, the doctor chose to attempt surgery on the correct eye – with Dryfhout no longer under anesthesia. The lawsuit filed by Dryfhout says Dr. Ticho came into the recovery room and told a nurse that he “forgot something” and then asked them to hold down the patient while he attempted to operate on her left eye. The nurse allegedly complied.

Speaking to New York Daily News, Dryfhout said she screamed and yelled for Dr. Ticho to stop and that she could “[feel] surgical instruments including a needle and scissors going into her eye and could feel burning from a cautery pen being used on her eye.” Dryfhout also alleges the ophthalmologist did not follow proper hygiene protocols by using unsterile equipment and performing the entire operation without gloves. After the impromptu surgery on the correct eye ended because of Dryfhout’s screams for help, Dr. Ticho allegedly went to the patient’s medical records and consent forms and changed all references to performing surgery on her “left eye” to her “right eye.”

Unsurprisingly, the botched surgery has left Dryfhout with vision problems and trauma. According to her lawsuit, she suffers from double vision and headaches but is too “terrified to have another surgery” because of her experience.  According to NBC Chicago, is suing the doctor for negligence, medical battery, assault, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Dryfhout says, “My main goal in all this is just making sure it won’t happen to anyone else.”

Dr. Ticho declined to comment on the lawsuit, citing patient privacy laws.

Contact our medical malpractice attorneys to discuss your potential case.

Contact Information